No Result
View All Result
  • Private Data
  • Membership options
  • Login
  • COUNTRY
    • ITALY
    • IBERIA
    • FRANCE
    • UK&IRELAND
    • BENELUX
    • DACH
    • SCANDINAVIA&BALTICS
  • PRIVATE EQUITY
  • VENTURE CAPITAL
  • PRIVATE DEBT
  • DISTRESSED ASSETS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • FINTECH
  • GREEN
  • PREMIUM
    • ItaHubHOT
      • ItaHub Legal
      • ItaHub Tax
      • ItaHub Trend
    • REPORT
    • INSIGHT VIEW
    • Private Data
Subscribe
  • COUNTRY
    • ITALY
    • IBERIA
    • FRANCE
    • UK&IRELAND
    • BENELUX
    • DACH
    • SCANDINAVIA&BALTICS
  • PRIVATE EQUITY
  • VENTURE CAPITAL
  • PRIVATE DEBT
  • DISTRESSED ASSETS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • FINTECH
  • GREEN
  • PREMIUM
    • ItaHubHOT
      • ItaHub Legal
      • ItaHub Tax
      • ItaHub Trend
    • REPORT
    • INSIGHT VIEW
    • Private Data
Home REAL ESTATE

Government’s rent caps ‘are a flawed policy’

Property Industry Eyeby Property Industry Eye
May 2, 2025
Reading Time: 3 mins read
in REAL ESTATE, UK&IRELAND
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
David Alexander

The Scottish governments’ announcement of a consultation on rent cap exemptions highlights just how confused their current policy is, according to DJ Alexander.

The Scottish letting and estate agency said that the idea that this consultation on exempting certain properties would clarify how rent caps would work is simply wrong.

Paul McLennan, Scottish minister for housing, said that: “There have been ongoing calls for further certainty on how rent controls will be implemented and how rents will be capped in areas where rent control applies. To respond to this, we are bringing forward this consultation to seek views on how the powers within the Housing Scotland Bill could be used to exempt certain types of properties from rent control and the circumstances where rents could be increased above the level of any introduced rent cap.”

Mclennan states that the Scottish government “is striking a balance between tenants and landlords” on rent controls with the aim of “focusing on local circumstances and seeking to stabilise rents for tenants in areas where they are rising too steeply, while an appropriate balance is in place to protect the property rights of landlords”.

The consultation considers that landlords could be allowed to increase rents above the rent cap if there have been improvements to their property or where rents have consistently been charged at a level below market rates.

However, the consultation could also produce a two-tier market as it proposes exempting build-to-rent (BTR) developers from rent controls. The consultation says BTR providers are typically long-term investors and provide a steady supply of homes.

David Alexander, the chief executive officer of DJ Alexander Scotland, commented: “This consultation, while welcome if it actually produces any real change, is simply tinkering at the edges of this policy when what is currently required is clarity and leadership.”

“Rather than providing a workable solution it is actually an admission that rent caps are a flawed policy that will only make the situation for renters worse. Consultation is, of course, an integral part of developing any coherent ideas or policy but this proposal would appear to create greater confusion and uncertainty and, crucially, result in further delays in actually doing anything meaningful to address the issues facing the private rented sector.”

Alexander continued: “Instead of further consultations and prevarication it would be helpful to have some concrete policies which would actually improve the PRS for landlords and tenants. The Irish Government is facing a similar housing emergency to Scotland and is considering a radical approach to encouraging growth in the private rented sector.”

“The new Taoiseach Micheal Martin has said that “We need to pivot more strongly to getting more private sector investment into the market” which will “entail politically very difficult decisions” including a review of the existing rent pressure zones in Ireland which is cited as a big stumbling block for investors. A report by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development recently suggested landlords in Ireland should be able to “reset” rents between tenancies – whenever they get in a new tenant to a property – to stop the exodus of investors from the market and boost the supply of rental property.”

“What we need then are big ideas to create more change. More consultations – while sounding good – can end up simply creating another talking shop. To create real growth there needs to be investment. The Irish Government seems to be considering quite a powerful policy of financial incentivisation to deliver growth in the private rented sector (PRS) and this, along with a realistic re-evaluation of any policy on rent caps would certainly go some way to addressing the current issues for landlords and investors in Scotland.”

 

Read the orginal article: https://propertyindustryeye.com/governments-rent-caps-are-a-flawed-policy/

Gateways to Italy

Gateways to Italy – Offer your services to funds and investors willing to explore opportunities in Italy. Become a partner!

Gateways to Italy – Offer your services to funds and investors willing to explore opportunities in Italy. Become a partner!

by Partner
June 6, 2023

Sign up to our newsletter

SIGN UP

Related Posts

GREEN

New firm Polarnode plans data center campuses across Finland

May 24, 2025
PRIVATE EQUITY

BT pushes on with fiber rollout, raises build target to 5 million premises for FY26

May 24, 2025
FRANCE

Paris overtakes London as Europe’s top startup hub, says report

May 24, 2025

ItaHub

Crypto-assets supervision rules in Italy, Banca d’Italia will supervise payment systems and Consob on market abuse

Crypto-assets supervision rules in Italy, Banca d’Italia will supervise payment systems and Consob on market abuse

November 4, 2024
Italy’s SMEs export toward 260 bn euros in 2025

Italy’s SMEs export toward 260 bn euros in 2025

September 9, 2024
With two months to go before the NPL Directive, in Italy the securitization rebus is still to be unraveled

With two months to go before the NPL Directive, in Italy the securitization rebus is still to be unraveled

April 23, 2024
EU’s AI Act, like previous rules on technology,  looks more defensive than investment-oriented

EU’s AI Act, like previous rules on technology, looks more defensive than investment-oriented

January 9, 2024

Co-sponsor

Premium

Funds vying for management consulting firm BIP, a CVC portfolio company. All deals in the sector

Funds vying for management consulting firm BIP, a CVC portfolio company. All deals in the sector

March 6, 2025
Private equity, Italy 2024 closes with 588 deals as for investments and divestments from 549 in 2023. Here is the new BeBeez’s report

Private equity, Italy 2024 closes with 588 deals as for investments and divestments from 549 in 2023. Here is the new BeBeez’s report

February 10, 2025
Crypto-assets supervision rules in Italy, Banca d’Italia will supervise payment systems and Consob on market abuse

Crypto-assets supervision rules in Italy, Banca d’Italia will supervise payment systems and Consob on market abuse

November 4, 2024
Venture capital investments top €1.3bn in 208 rounds as of Sep30  in Italy. They were €1.5 in all 2023. The new BeBeez Report

Venture capital investments top €1.3bn in 208 rounds as of Sep30 in Italy. They were €1.5 in all 2023. The new BeBeez Report

October 28, 2024
Next Post

Could Trump pull the plug on European tech?

Revolut and N26 want to disrupt the telecoms industry. Can they succeed?

EdiBeez srl

C.so Italia 22 - 20122 - Milano
C.F. | P.IVA 09375120962
Aut. Trib. Milano n. 102
del 3 aprile 2013

COUNTRY

Italy
Iberia
France
UK&Ireland
Benelux
DACH
Scandinavia&Baltics

CATEGORY

Private Equity
Venture Capital
Private Debt
Distressed Assets
Real Estate
Fintech
Green

PREMIUM

ItaHUB
Legal
Tax
Trend
Report
Insight view

WHO WE ARE

About Us
Media Partnerships
Contact

INFORMATION

Privacy Policy
Terms&Conditions
Cookie Police

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • COUNTRY
    • ITALY
    • IBERIA
    • FRANCE
    • UK&IRELAND
    • BENELUX
    • DACH
    • SCANDINAVIA&BALTICS
  • PRIVATE EQUITY
  • VENTURE CAPITAL
  • PRIVATE DEBT
  • DISTRESSED ASSETS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • FINTECH
  • GREEN
  • PREMIUM
    • ItaHub
      • ItaHub Legal
      • ItaHub Tax
      • ItaHub Trend
    • REPORT
    • INSIGHT VIEW
    • Private Data
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Cart